I Found the Toothpaste I've Been Searching For (A Review of Earthpaste) 1

I Found the Toothpaste I’ve Been Searching For (A Review of Earthpaste)

Wintergreen Tubeand Box.white 1

Finding a toothpaste that met all of my requirements hasn’t been easy. I wanted something that:

  • had no fluoride
  • had no toxic ingredients like sodium lauryl sulfate
  • had no glycerin (which can coat teeth and interfere with the work that saliva is meant to do to help protect teeth from decay)
  • wasn’t homemade (I know it works very well for many people, and there’s even a popular recipe on this website, but my family hasn’t loved it to this point)
  • aided the remineralization process, actually helping to heal teeth

I thought we would eventually land on a coconut-oil based toothpaste, or perhaps find a tooth soap that my family found acceptable. I wasn’t sure that the remineralizing aspect would happen, nor was I completely confident that I would find a flavor and texture that everyone actually approved of.

About 6 weeks ago, I began to talk with Redmond Trading Company about how we could partner and share their fantastic products. They sent me a box of things to try out, which included their newest addition, Earthpaste.

It honestly seemed too good to be true. I had been learning so much this past year about using bentonite clay, as well as the importance of upping mineral content in our diets in my studies about tooth health. So when I received my toothpaste, I eagerly read the ingredients:

  • Purified Water
  • Food Grade Redmond Clay
  • Xylitol
  • Redmond Real Salt
  • Tea Tree Oil
  • Menthol (found in peppermint and wintergreen Earthpaste flavors)
  • Essential Oils (like Cinnamon or Peppermint, depends on flavor)

It sounded perfect.

All that was left was to test it out. I was shocked to hear from every single member of the family that it was a winner. Even my husband. Wow.

I genuinely love Redmond products and am thrilled to recommend a company whose products I can 100% support.

But back to the Earthpaste… let me answer some questions that I’m sure are on your minds.

earthpaste flavors

Will it taste like eating dirt?

This was my hubby’s first question and it’s a valid one. His answer?;Surprisingly, it doesn’t!

We were talking about it last night and he said that he gets just a slight clay-ish feel briefly after brushing, but not for long, and not enough to bother him (and I have to tell you, he’s very sensitive to tastes and textures that he doesn’t like– more than most people). I find that after it’s been in my mouth for 30 seconds, I also sense the clay just a bit. You can actually swallow this toothpaste without worry, because there’s nothing harmful in it at all, but I find with a quick water rinse, any hint of clay goes away.

Does it foam up?

Nope. There aren’t any foaming agents like sodium lauryl sulfate in it, nor does it contain any manner of soap.

For most people, this is a different sensation. Many find the initial switch over to a non-foaming natural toothpaste of any sort a big change, because we’ve become convinced that foam = clean. It’s not true. Which leads to the next question…

Will my teeth feel clean?

Yes! Both Ryan and I commented on how clean our teeth feel using Earthpaste. Every bit as clean as with any conventional toothpaste, and in some way I can’t put into words, almost cleaner.

Does it taste good?

We’re currently trying two of the three flavors, Wintergreen and Cinnamon (the other is Peppermint, which I’m eager to try). The Cinnamon is decent tasting, a more mild flavor, and none of us mind using it, but for us, it’s the Wintergreen that sold us. The taste is wonderful and you wouldn’t even know that it’s a clay-based toothpaste. I’m truly impressed at how good they made it taste.

Ryan also said that I should mention the lack of gritty texture. He thought that it might actually feel like brushing his teeth with something sandy or slightly gritty, but the texture is completely smooth and appealing.

redmond clay

Why use clay at all?

Clay is an incredible substance. In the past year, I’ve been really exploring it, for both internal and external purposes. It is particularly helpful for detoxification, as well as for all manner of digestive issues. We’ve also found it;indispensable;in our “medicine” cabinet, where we make pastes to put on scrapes and cuts, on bug bites or;allergic;reactions or irritated skin in general.

I’ve been using it in the bath water for our two middle children for about 8 months, for detoxification and to help our youngest daughter’s eczema. I’ve noticed the the eczema is less red and itchy when she takes regular clay baths, and I think it does help our son’s body to stay less toxic (he seems to struggle with eliminating toxins).

Clay also contains a wide array of naturally;occurring;minerals. Many cultures have historically used clay as a mineral supplement. In Nourishing Traditions, Azomite clay is recommended in the “superfood” section as a way to increase the mineral content of your diet. Our family uses Azomite clay;(this link goes to the one that I bought);in our smoothies, and although Bentonite clay (the type that is in Earthpaste) known particularly for its minerals as Azomite is, it certainly does include calcium, magnesium, among other things.

If you want to learn more about clay and its benefits, you can download a free ebook here.

Real Salt

Why include salt?

Redmond says that the sea salt (Redmond’s pure RealSalt brand) is added to enhance flavor, as well as for the antibacterial qualities of salt,;which;makes sense. I would add that sea salt is also an important source of trace minerals in our diet, and adding trace minerals to a toothpaste is likely to aid in remineralization. I’ll admit, I can’t prove this statement. I just think it’s true.

What about xylitol?

I’m just not sure yet. I’ve heard and read so many good things about xylitol for teeth, but then also not-so-good things about xylitol as a healthy thing to eat. I wish I had a solid answer for you, but my answer is still “I don’t know just yet”.

We’re playing this one conservatively. We spit the toothpaste (even though you don’t need to), and don’t use xylitol as a regular sweetener in our home, although if we want to chew gum, we occasionally use the xylitol kind from the health food store, because pretty much every other type of gum includes aspartame, which is a known neurotoxin adn an absolute no-no in our home.

Is it expensive?

Yes, it is a bit expensive. I won’t lie. Redmond sells it for $7.99 per tube (and so far, not too many of the bigger online or brick-and-mortar stores are carrying it, since it’s so new). I’m used to paying more like $4-$5 for natural toothpaste.

That said, I’m committed to buying Earthpaste once we run out of our review product. For us, using something that I feel is not only safe, but actually helps protect our teeth, is worth the extra few dollars. Repairing cavities is a whole lot more expensive than mildly pricey toothpaste.

Update (from a comment below): When you order from the Redmond website, for a limited time;get a 15% discount on your entire order if you order Earthpaste online. (Use coupon code TryEarthpaste.)

Also, if you order $35 or more, you get free shipping.

Edit: Some readers have been asking where to buy it, other than the Redmond site that I linked to. One reader found it at WebVitamins. If you know of anywhere else to buy it, please let us know in the comments! And… it’s now on Amazon, for $4.58 per tube (plus shipping)!

I Found the Toothpaste I've Been Searching For (A Review of Earthpaste) {Keeper of the Home}

What do you think? Clay in toothpaste? What are your requirements for a toothpaste?

Similar Posts


  1. Thank you for this. I’ve only just begun researching toothpaste and know we need to switch from mass-produced store bought toxic stuff, but my family hasn’t liked the natural options either. I’m ordering some today!

  2. Sounds like a great toothpaste! We do something similiar by just using Living Clay and Thieves Essential Oil from my favorite, high-quality essential oil company. Thanks for all the great information you provide!

  3. This is amazing! You’re right – it appears to be exactly what I’ve been looking for for my family. I’ve made my own toothpaste as well, but I don’t always have the time to do so, and my oldest daughter hasn’t always been a fan of my concoctions.

    1. I hear ya, Monique! My oldest, 5, says that it makes a sour taste on her tongue. And…it’s peppermint. /sigh

  4. thank you for this post! I have been waiting for a better toothpaste to come out as well since my family can’t stand the ones we’ve tried. I will be ordering some soon.

  5. I have been buying Trader Joe’s toothpaste for a while now, because it doesn’t have any flouride or SLS in it. We like it just fine, but it does include glycerin. So, I recently found a recipe for tooth powder that includes bentonite clay and made some of it. Honestly, I think it makes my teeth feel cleaner than just about any other thing we’ve tried, including tooth soap. I’m a firm believer in the process of tooth remineralization now. Here’s my experience with having cavities healed, if you’re interested. http://ramblingsofahappyhomemaker.blogspot.com/2012/02/can-cavity-be-healed.html Thanks for sharing this toothpaste with us. I’m glad to know there’s a better option available for purchase. ๐Ÿ™‚

    1. Thank you for sharing your story! I can’t wait to read it! One of my daughter’s teeth healed somewhat this past fall/winter, and two of my friends are working to heal/remineralize their daughter’s cavities (and they’re chronicling their progress- I hope to post about it sometime this summer!).

  6. I have an article on xylitol that I copied a few years ago. If you would like for me to e-mail you a copy, let me know! Not sure if it would paste on here — it is 6 pages!

  7. we used A homemade bentonite clay tooth paste for about six months with Redmond salt. We now have cavities we are trying to remineralize and heal through the homemade toothpaste recipe on your website. We have 8 people in our family, it is hard to satisfy each person by taste, so we try for a while, a good 6 mo, and see. With the coconut oil based tooth paste on your website, it seems to be helping, plus it is more cost effective for our family. We will see.

  8. Sounds like a great toothpaste! We are honestly still using a fluoride toothpaste-Tom’s of Maine, or I just purchased the Trader Joe’s version for the first time the other day. This is something I’ve definitely been thinking about and want to research more. I had a guest poster write about a very easy, homemade tooth powder that I want to try. TJ’s also sells a non-fluoride toothpaste.

  9. This sounds intriguing. Have you tried Jason Healthy Mouth Toothpaste Tea Tree and Cinnamon? I think there are other flavors too, but I like cinnamon, although it’s not a dominant flavor in this. I have been pleased with this toothpaste. My mouth feels fresh and clean after using it and you only use a pea sized amount. It also does not have SLS or fluoride.

    1. Just my preference, but I’m not fond of Jason’s because of the glycerin. We currently are using Ora Wellness. Five out of six in the family love it. The sixth absolutely hates clove oil. Just went to the dentist yesterday and found no cavities. ๐Ÿ™‚

  10. Very interesting…I think I’ll have to try some of this after I run out of toothpaste. However, I must admit – I am quite addicted to the foaming action of toothpaste. ๐Ÿ™‚

  11. Thank you for the review. I have been trying to keep my son off food coloring, but I have had no luck finding a good toothpaste without food dye. Do you know where this can be purchased?

  12. wow! this sounds amazing! I’ve just been turned onto the benefits of clay so this peaked my interest.

  13. Curious, I have a two year old boy, would it be okay to use with small children that may swallow it? Probably, but I just want your opinion! Also, how much do you use at a time for yourself (pea size or smaller)? Based on your recommendation, I am definitely buying this! Thanks for the great info ๐Ÿ™‚ Blessings!

  14. I believe Dr. David Brownstein, a holistic doctor, has given his approval for Xylitol although I know other doctors have not. I’ve trusted Dr. Brownstein’s advice for my Hashimoto’s for a few years now, and I’ll trust him on Xylitol. I’d really like to try Earthpaste, but don’t think I can get my hubby to agree to the price. He’s already balking al the $4 – $5 dollar prices I currently pay.

  15. We’ve been using this for a couple months now and love it! I love the fact it does not foam and does not have a super strong flavor. I also love the fact I can swallow it (I do only use a smidge) and can brush my teeth when I’m out more easily (no need to rinse and spit over and over to get the regular toothpaste out). My favorite is the cinnamon because it has such a mild flavor. I do like the wintergreen too. Haven’t tried the peppermint. ๐Ÿ™‚

  16. I have been using this for a couple months now. I love the mild flavor and lack of foam, cinnamon is my favorite. The kids like the wintergreen. We haven’t tried the peppermint. I also like that I “can” swallow it . . . makes it easier to brush my teeth away from home . . . don’t need to spit out all that toxic foam. I can actually put a blob on my toothbrush now, instead of just smearing a little on the edge. Two thumbs up for Earthpaste! ๐Ÿ™‚

  17. I was very interested in this post because I went to the dentist yesterday, and he said the reason I was having pain is because the dentin was exposed. (I can’t remember 100% if he used the word dentin, but the main point was that it would hurt if cold or hot went past that spot.) He said that I needed to never use baking soda because it was overkill for me. My teeth would try to remineralize, and then I was brushing it all back off with the baking soda. He gave me Sensodyne to use at least for a couple of weeks to fix the sensitivity problem. It had flouride and the dentist’s assistant said “She watches everything she uses” Then looked at me and said “You don’t use flouride, do you?” I love going to a biological dentist. ๐Ÿ™‚ But the dentist asked if there was a flouride free Sensodyne, and the assistant replied that they can’t get it that way. The dentist said that it wouldn’t hurt to use for a few weeks to help heal the sensitivity. I had been using Ecodent powder.
    I would love to know if the salt in this toothpaste would have the same effect as the baking soda because I would think salt would also be abrasive. I am still on the search for the perfect toothpaste-no flouride, no glycerin, not abrasive, and helps teeth to not get cavities. It would be wonderful if this was the one. ๐Ÿ™‚

    1. I’m not sure whether the salt is abrasive or not. I’ll tell you that I’ve tried baking soda toothpastes, and I could feel that they were slightly abrasive. The Earthpaste doesn’t feel that way to me, but of course, it’s hard to tell. I would give it a try, though, if I were you. It sounds like a fit for you.

      And dentist’s don’t really love me, either. ๐Ÿ™‚

    2. Look here for a recipe to make your own, http://www.bulkherbstore.com/Bentonite-Clay-Toothpaste-Kit see the comments, they say to leave out salt & baking soda IF you have an issue w/sensitive teeth/etc. I’m drying my own stevia leaves…all I need to do is buy whole cloves or figure out how to use clove essential oil, then I plan to make it. Here is where I buy my essential oils, bentonite clay & other items http://www.morethanalive.com/?a_aid=837c265b (my referral link ๐Ÿ™‚

  18. Cool! I’m excited to know about this toothpaste. Like you, my search for the perfect toothpaste product has been never -ending. Looking forward to trying it.

  19. I called the Earthpaste company after reading the blog and had many questions. The lady was extremely informative and helpful in answering. She had actually worked for a company in which we’ve been using their toothpaste for the last few years but we just can’t afford to buy the amount of products monthly via this company. With 7 children and the price of toothpaste, it does get spendy. We were able to acquire some samples first from Earthpaste. Thanks Earthpaste!! There are some things in life we just need to splurge on that WILL make a difference overall in the health of our children. Toothpaste is becoming one of them! Love this blog!!!

  20. I’m interested to try this one! I just ordered a tube and will be sure to give feedback when we have tried it for a while. Stephanie, thanks so much for opening up our eyes through your blog. You truly are an inspiration to so many of us who are wanting to raise our families in the most natural way possible ๐Ÿ™‚

  21. Thank you for the post. I use the UltraShine Radianceยฎ Toothpaste, from Neways.com for years now. It meets all of your requirements too, without the tee tree oil (I do not react well to tee tree oil) and clay.

    1. I just posted this in case somebody else is looking for a Tea Tree Oil free product. I know there are great natural products out there mostly containing the oil. Otherwise I would have loved to try the Earthpaste.

  22. Not sure if another reader already mentioned this, but it seems you can get Earthpaste on Amazon.com for under $5 a tube. To me that is a very reasonable price for natural toothpaste and I may well be trying it soon! Homemade hasn’t worked for us either, although my husband is a real champ and has been using up the one I last made but didn’t like. I’ve been trying different recipes that have remineralizing components in them, but none tasted very good, so this may be the answer for us. Thanks for posting this!

  23. Do you know if it is better for sensitive teeth? We currently use Tom’s of Maine Flouride free. But hubby has thin enamle from brushing too hard.
    Also wanted to mention the sentence about bentonite vs azomite clay seems to be missing the word not or something ๐Ÿ˜‰
    Thanks for a great post!

  24. Thanks for posting this! I have tried the samples they sent me (they are a very generous company) and I also am sold on the wintergreen flavor. My mouth feels so much better than it ever has with any other natural toothpaste. I have considered buying the clay and making my own as well. I don’t want to mess up a good thing though. I do have one question for you though. Is wintergreen in this way okay during pregnancy? I looked into buying wintergreen oil and got scared when I read it was so dangerous. I am not pregnant now, but I am just wondering about wintergreen during my next pregnancy. Also, is it okay to use the toothpaste with wintergreen for babies/toddlers. My son just got his first 2 teeth and I have just been using water for now. Thanks!

  25. I myself am a fan of xylitol, in moderation of course. We alternate the kids’ toothpastes (Spry’s xylitol and Tom’s of Maine kids’) and we have have a few strategic xylitol mints throughout the day. Add in a once-everyday-or-two mouthwash rinse with ACT (I know, most folks on here will be totally against that, I get it), and my 6yo has a cavity that’s started healing up. Was pretty sticky in January, less-sticky in February, and not sticky at all in May, just from those changes. We’ve added in BO/FCLO to the regimen to see if that helps even more by the next dental appointment. Yes, this mommy is totally using her kids as little science experiments (complete with photos!) to see if/how I can get things to work for us.

    Anyway. What xylitol does for my family is stimulate saliva production. So the saliva can get to work helping to remineralize the teeth. I’ve even noticed I need to be careful to space it out otherwise I turn into the amazing spitting-while-talking woman because of all the fun saliva production going on.

  26. Thanks ever so much for sharing that discount code. I used it this morning to try some toothpaste and some clay — got free shipping too! Hoping the clay will relieve me of eczema and my youngest son of occasional constipation (he’s two years old). But I am excited about another way to build our health naturally.

  27. I live in a rural area of Maine, and I purchase most of my natural products at iHerb.com. They have Earthpaste for $5.12. I am going to try it. Thanks!

  28. Earthpaste delivers all the benefits you expect from a toothpaste without any chemicals or unnatural additives. Itโ€™s toothpaste unlike any other youโ€™ve experienced โ€” youโ€™ll see the difference on your brush and feel the difference in your mouth.

  29. Another decent toothpaste is Coral white. Free of everything nasty including soap.
    I am going to try Earthpaste to see if it will finish healing my teeth. Switching to Coral White at the beginning of the year helped quiet a bit but seems to have stalled.

  30. Oh I am so glad I happened across this blog post. I really want to try this now! Teeth problems seem to run in my family, and my poor 4 year old is having problems already. We have made a lot of much healthier changes in the past year and toothpaste is one I have been struggling with. I am actually taking her back to the dentist AGAIN this week because her temporary filling fell out (I literally can not remember how many times we have been to the dentist since February and we could have gone on vacation TWICE with what we have spent) I need to go too but I am terrified of how much it will cost. Learning how bad most things are for people these days has been scary, I can understand why some people get overwhelmed and have the “I don’t want to know” or “Everything is bad for you anyways” attitude. But I feel sorry for them because they are not making the changes that will actually help them be healthier. Anyways thanks again and sorry for rambling lol.

  31. I too have tried Earthpaste and I love it. I was shocked to taste that it wasn’t disgusting basically. I happened on this review awhile ago and only read as far as the toothpaste & just now read about the red clay. My son suffers from eczema so I think I’ll the the sample a received a try & see what happens. Thanks! ๐Ÿ™‚

  32. I bought my first tube of Earthpaste today, have brushed with it twice, and already love it! I bought Peppermint, and the only eight ingredients sold me. My teeth feel clean and it gets rid of bad tastes. I wholly support this product! It will be interesting to see how it holds up long-term.

  33. I just got the earthpaste from a healthy living bundle and am excited to use it. My kids haven’t been to keen on the DIY toothpastes/powders I have made. Still looking for the right recipe.
    I found it for 4.59 on vitacost.com. That will probably be where we reorder from if we like it.

  34. I also received the deal with Earthpaste from the Healthy Living ebook bundle and my husband and I LOVE it. I have been considering writing a review about how great this toothpaste is and I was happy to see your posting about it! We have tried the peppermint and cinnamon flavors so far, but are excited to try wintergreen now too. I would say the cinnamon kind of tastes like a cinnamon candle, if that makes any sense. I actually feel like between the cinnamon and the peppermint, I feel the cinnamon cleans my teeth much better. However, I like having peppermint breath more than cinnamon. Also, there is a huge difference when I use my manual (firm bristle) toothbrush compared to when I brush with my Sonicare toothbrush. For some reason, my teeth feel much cleaner with the manual toothbrush. I have always had trouble getting my upper molars completely clean and I have had to wipe the backs of my teeth with Q-tips after each brushing. I know it sounds kind of silly. But with a manual toothbrush and Earthpaste ALL my teeth are squeaky clean! Just thought I’d write if the info could help anyone! I think I will start buying it from Vitacost.com too because it is cheaper there. Thanks so much!

  35. In your opinion, Wintergreen oil, tea tree oil and menthol are ok to use with very small children who will swallow it? I wouldn’t mind my toddler swallowing the clay!

  36. After hearing what is in conventional toothpastes, such as glycerin, I looked for a natural toothpaste. I’ve used Tom’s of Main toothpaste, but that actually has glycerin in it too. I’ve wondered throughout the years why my teeth rapidly decayed and became prone to infections despite brushing them and using mouthwash. Now I know the answer. That being said I have switched to earthpaste (my eleven year old niece actually found it for me). I have been using it for the past three days, and I have to say I honestly like it. My teeth feel cleaner and even smoother than they had with conventional toothpastes. I know it’s expensive, but that’s perfectly fine with me.

    I will also be switching to a more natural mouthwash, one without glycerin or other bad chemicals and toxins. I wonder if Redmond sells such a product?

  37. Hi, this Earthpaste sounds very interesting I think I’m going to give it a try. My kids just went to the dentist and one of them has a mouth full of cavities! I have a question, do you know of any natural remedies for constipation. My 6 year old has had an issue with constipation since he was a baby. I just feel like there has got to be something out there that can help him. Thanks, Kimberlee

  38. I use redmond clay in my homemade toothpaste and I am sure that this manufactured one is excellent though I have not tried it personally.

  39. Yay! Keep posting the helpful info. I’m so happy to have found your website. Big smiles ๐Ÿ™‚

  40. I just came across this post when I searched for a review of this product on google. I am looking it up because it is on sale this and next month at Azure Standard for $3.40 for a 4 oz tube (or $3.11 per tube if you buy 12). Looking forward to trying it!!

  41. Greetings! Sorrry to comment on such and old post. I’ve been trying to find a glycerin free toothpaste for some time. Not because of its coating effects, but because it contributes to tooth sensitivity for those prone to it like me, I’ve been reading about all the folks that like Earthpaste. Do you have any concerns about the tree tea oil ingredient? WebMD seems to suggest it shouldn’t be ingested and should not be used by still developing boys. http://www.webmd.com/vitamins-supplements/ingredientmono-113-TEA%20TREE%20OIL.aspx?activeIngredientId=113&activeIngredientName=TEA%20TREE%20OIL

    Maybe there’s not enough tea tree oil to worry about it?

  42. My concern is the menthol. I’ve heard that this can have adverse effects is used continuously. Anyone else?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *